Indispensable Glass

This post was originally featured on TechZulu

Hypothesis: users of every major computing platform have come to consider each platform indispensable for their daily activities in both consumer and enterprise contexts. Let’s examine each of the major computing platforms to understand this assertion:

Desktops

The killer app that drove desktop PC adoption was Excel. Through the 90s, Word, email, and general web browsing drove adoption for the masses. It’s hard to argue that desktop computing isn’t indispensable to modern businesses. They will be, even in Steve Jobs view, always around, though perhaps as trucks instead of cars.

Cellphones

Business executives and heavy-travelers drove cellphone adoption because they empowered those individuals to communicate on the road. As the form factor became pocket friendly, it was inevitable that consumers would adopt them. Obviously, cellphones are indispensable today.

MP3 players

Although MP3 players never reached 98% penetration in any market, they reached a substantial percentage of society. Most MP3 player-toters, most considered the device indispensable for at least one reason, if not multiple. Possible reasons included: work out companion, being a music junkie, traveling, airplanes, and to escape reality. MP3 players solved at least one of many significant problems for their users. Mobile MP3 listeners never wanted to go back to life without mobile music.

iPad

The iPad has become essential to mobile workers (hospitals, field service workers, many retail staff, etc) because of the form factor. It’s become indispensable to consumers for at least one of any number of reasons, even among those that use a PC all day at work. The potential uses are many: unwilling or unable to deal with the complexity of PCs, reading, using in bed, keeping kids busy, touch-based games. Although the iPad hasn’t reached 95% adoption, the vast majority of iPad users don’t want to go back to a life pre-iPad.

What about Glass?

What problems will Glass solve so that users are unwilling to go back to life without it? The enterprise use cases are clear: as a corporate owned and managed device, employers will dictate that employees use it in cases where it creates value per some economic value unit (customer transaction, patient interaction, field service repair, etc).

Will consumers find glass to be indispensable? If they forget Glass at home in the morning, will they feel pain all day? I struggle to understand that pain since consumers will fall back on their smartphone if they leave Glass at home. Glass doesn’t actually “do” anything more than a smartphone, so I’m not sure what pain consumers will feel if they leave Glass at home.

Interview with Alexis Savvy

Alexis Savvy, a fellow forward thinking health IT blogger, recently interviewed me. The interview is reproduced below.

 

When Google revealed Google Glass, the first question I got asked was, “How will this change healthcare?” There is no one better to answer that question than Kyle Samani, Founder and CEO of Pristine, a startup in Austin, TX that develops Google Glass apps for surgery. Kyle is also a healthcare blogger, writing for HIStalk and TechZulu. Kyle answered my most pressing questions about his journey from first seeing Glass, to creating Pristine.

When did you first try Google Glass and when did you know that it would change healthcare?

I wore Google Glass for the first time in February of this year. The light bulb went off instantly because I’d been working in the electronic health record (EHR) industry for 3 years. I spent one year as an engineering team lead, one year as technical sales lead, and one year as product manager for a wide variety of clinical applications (EHR, CPOE, Perioperative care, LIS, RIS, PACS, PAS, Patient Portal, etc), so I got to see the development, sales, and deployment cycles of health IT from a bunch of unique perspectives. With that knowledge and experience, it was immediately clear to me that Glass would drive an array of new point-of-care apps.

Since my background was in EHRs, the original vision for the company was to extend the EHR onto Glass. I gave up on that by mid-May, just as I recruited Patrick, my cofounder and CTO. We threw that vision away because we realized that it would be impossible to overcome HL7 integration challenges. Our first investor was an anesthesiologist, and he really opened our eyes to the opportunities for Glass in the OR. We’ve been actively working on what are now Pristine CheckLists and Pristine EyeSight since late May.

What is Pristine’s mission?

Pristine’s mission: We empower healthcare professionals to deliver safer, more coordinated, more cost effective care by utilizing cutting edge technologies to do what was once impossible.

Essentially, we want to pioneer new technologies in medicine to help healthcare professionals deliver care in ways that were never before possible. Our engineering team has deep technical expertise across almost ever layer of the technology stack, and substantial experience with almost every major field of human computer interaction (HCI), including audio, video, touch, gesture sensing, and more. Our business team knows the modern US healthcare environment, with years of experience working closely for or with payers, providers, and technology vendors. We hold strong views as to where things are going, and we work closely with our engineering teams and the latest technologies to shape what we believe will be the future of care delivery.

You are one of the first companies to innovate in this space. What’s it like being on the forefront?

As exciting as it is to pioneer new technologies, it’s also been quite challenging. For example, one of the greatest impediments to Pristine’s success today is, unfortunately, lack of hardware. Google is not helping enterprise-focused developers such as ourselves; they are completely consumer-focused. We have 10 Glass units today, with 12 or so inbound. Until recently, we really didn’t have enough hardware to roll out Glass widely.

We’re trying to break one of the most fundamental assumptions in care delivery: that you need to be in room X to provide value and care in room X. We need as many hardware units as possible in as many rooms as possible to prove the value. If you or anyone you know has a Glass or some spare Glass invites, can you please email me? It would really help us perform more rigorous testing across a range of care environments.

Besides lack of hardware, we’re dealing with what are pretty common technical issues when you’re on the forefront of technology: buggy hardware and software. Our technical foundation, Glass hardware and a modified version of Android, still have lots of problems, but that’s to be expected. In many ways, it provides our engineers with enticing challenges, although as CEO I wish we encountered fewer technical hurdles.

On the other hand, the business side of things has been incredible. I’m a first time entrepreneur, and I can safely say this has been the single most important, most educational, most fun thing I’ve ever done in my life. I think that rings true for every one of our employees as well. I’ve read about how hard it is to get off the ground and answer the existential startup question. We’ve been incredibly lucky that so many talented people, doctors, provider organizations, and investors have supported us so early on. Very few startups have the opportunity to raise as much capital as we have, and even fewer have the opportunity to so quickly deploy and test across over half a dozen clinical departments in live care environments, including the OR, ICU, and ER.

What’s amazing is that we’re just at the beginning of what can be done. We’re at the cusp of a major hardware renaissance powered by increasingly small yet powerful mobile systems-on-a-chip (SoCs). These SoCs are driving a quantified civilization. Pristine is incredibly excited to figure out how to support providers at the point of care using these new technologies.

Tell us what you are hoping your current Glass products will do for the healthcare system.

We’re trying to shape the next generation of telemedicine solutions. To be clear, we’re not trying to compete with Teladoc or Ringadoc and the dozens of at-home, self-service telemedicine companies that’re springing up. We’re delivering telemedicine solutions when patients are already interacting with care providers.

Mobile cameras, processors, and Wi-Fi antennas are good enough to deliver telemedicine anytime, anywhere, in 1st person. That means that we’re enabling telemedicine and video communications literally everywhere in every care environment. But our ambitions extend far beyond telemedicine. Pristine EyeSight (1st person audio and video streaming) will become the de facto training tool for most jobs that require hands-on work.

In addition to telemedicine and communications, we’re also using Glass to implement process control where it was never before ergonomically possible. Because Glass is inherently hands-free, we can implement checklists literally anywhere in the hospital, and that’s exactly what we’re doing. We believe that checklists should be implemented in any process in which the cost of being wrong is unacceptable: instrument cleaning, drug preparation, complicated tests and procedures, etc.

You are running a pilot with UC Irvine. How has that been and what have you learned?

I’ve personally worked with staff at over 2 dozen hospitals. I can safely say that the staff across every department – IT, surgeons, anesthesiologists, nurses, ICU, ER, sim lab – at UC Irvine have been the best I’ve ever worked with. They are forward thinking, open to new ideas and new ways of doing things, and understanding that this is a beta product. Despite all of the technical challenges we face, they’ve been extremely supportive and accommodating. We cannot thank them enough for their patience and for helping us refine our software. We didn’t realize how difficult the testing process would be for our solutions: there are literally dozens of opportunities for failure that are completely outside of our control. We have been extremely fortunate to work with a group of people that want to see us succeed.

We have learned a tremendous amount at UC Irvine. First and foremost, audio and video streaming is just the tip of the iceberg. We’ve developed just as much supporting technology as we have core audio/video streaming. Delivering a seamless, elegant, user experience on a new form factor requires a lot of thought, a lot of refinement, and a lot of work. The best technology is the least visible. We’ve spent an enormous amount of time working to make the entire user experience – unboxing, setup, training, charging, updating, connecting, communicating, disconnecting, etc. – look easy and seamless. We assume responsibility for everything that directly impacts the user experience across software, hardware, and training and deployment methodologies.

As an entrepreneur, what is one piece of advice you’d give to people who are thinking about starting their own company?

First, I would read all of my blog posts about entrepreneurship. I don’t mean to selfishly promote, but I’ve spent a great deal of time addressing this question and try to provide tips, tricks, and advice for others so that they don’t make the same mistakes I did. I’m certainly not the most qualified to tell aspiring entrepreneurs how to develop ideas, customer development, product / market fit, and some of the other major startup principles, but I have a knack for hacking the world to get things done.

I think the most important thing that I’ve learned is not to give up. Some days are really bad. I’ll develop short-lived doubts. Other days are spectacularly good.

I am, for the first time in my life, accountable not just to one or two other people, but dozens: employees, their families, advisors, investors, partners, and prospects. Everyone has bet on me and our team. Once we’re live with our 1.0 product, I’ll be accountable to tens of thousands of patients that I will never meet.

Whenever something goes wrong, I feel my stomach drop, and I worry that I’m going to let down all of my stakeholders. I cannot describe the feeling, but I can tell you that it’s one of the most unnerving feelings in the world. I literally live and breathe Pristine all day, everyday, and sensing that it could vanish provides for a mental roller coaster ride.

Maintaining stature during challenging times is one of the great signs of leadership. I’m still learning how to do that, but I think it’s one of the hardest and most important things entrepreneurs, particularly startup CEOs, can do.

 

The Power of Digital Queues

 

I love digital queues. Why? Because I can move through them with ruthless efficiency. Queues empower me to consume and interact with enormous volumes of data in quick succession. Queues include, but aren't limited to emails, RSS feeds, tweets, Pocket articles, Chrome tabs, even my own blog posts on Draft.

Why do queues work? What's the magic?

Queues work because they're repetitive. Repetitive actions don't require thinking. When I'm working through a queue of content, regardless of the type of content, I can effectively ignore everything but the content itself. The queuing mechanism is so good that the mechanism itself goes away; all that remains is pure content.

For example, when I'm going through my daily feed of about 400 articles, I keep my finger hovering over the "next" button. My eyes stay fixed on the top of the screen. I can blast through headlines in less than half a second because my brain has learned to quickly read titles, process them, and make a lightning decision to skip them or dive deeper. This is only possible because I can repeat the same 2-3 steps in quick succession. If there was even the slightest variability - changing the font, the location of the headline on the screen, or moving the "next" button even half an inch, my productive would instantly drop 50%.

The same is true of emails and subject lines. I can process an email subject in less than half a second and decide if it requires additional thought or action. If it doesn't, I can archive it instantly. On the desktop, this requires pressing the "Delete" key, and in Mailbox on my iPhone, a quick swipe to the right.

This concept can be thought of more broadly across all forms of design. The more frequently a function or series of steps will be performed, the easier it should be.

 

The Internet Accelerates Everything

This post was originally featured on TechZulu

Commerce and trade are fundamentally based on exchanging asymmetries in one another’s ability to produce value at a given cost. As such, commerce intrinsically creates mutual value. That’s why it works. Moreover, the option to trade with more parties creates more value by fostering larger volumes of and more competitive trading.

Because of this, capitalism is infectious and self-reinforcing. As countries trade more, they create more and desire more value, which encourages more trade (not unlike Facebook and sharing). That explains why, in less than 250 years, capitalism has become the dominant socioeconomic system across the globe. Not only does capitalism govern economics, it heavily influences social norms and politics.

Of course, there are physical and geographic limits to trade. Analog and digital technologies have amplified capitalism’s viral growth by connecting more people to trade more frequently. Through the first 200 years of capitalism (starting symbolically in 1788), capitalism spread through analog channels: boats, trains, bikes, cars, airplanes, etc. The Internet changed everything. The Internet dramatically accelerated the proliferation of capitalism by opening digital channels to exchange information.

The Internet accelerates everything: e.g. the spread of social norms, news, political trends, business practices. For example, I recently learned that Waze (which Google just bought for a cool $1B) mapped the entirety of Costa Rica, a country in which it had no operations or expertise, in under 3 months. That’s remarkable. They mapped an entire country literally without trying.

The Internet also accelerates the fall of institutions, both large and small. Perhaps my favorite example of this over the past few years was Chat Roulette – I’ve never seen a business rise and fall so quickly. There’re any number of number of businesses that have succumbed to the Internet’s volatility: Zynga, OMGPOP (which Zynga infamously acquired), Groupon, Foursquare, Yelp, and Pandora, to name a few.

Yet, there are some processes that the Internet hasn’t digitized. Many businesses, particularly high-touch, people-centric businesses, still require large swaths of people doing stuff in a specific locations.

Why hasn’t the Internet digitized these functions yet? Is it a matter of time? If so, what’s the tipping point? What if we could digitize, accelerate, and reduce the cost of these services? How would we do it?

The simple answer is to digitize the human. Turn him / her into a computer. This is, of course, artificial intelligence (AI), and it’s the most radical approach to solving the problem. I strongly believe in the long-term prospects for AI, but, in the short to medium term, it’s probably safe to say that AI won’t replace people.

So, what if we could just put a cheaper person or object on the ground, and send in the high-touch person? Beam is attempting this by what amounts to gluing an iPad to an engine and set of wheels. The obvious problem of course is that many people might be turned off by the Beam. It’s anything but graceful and agile.

Eyeware computers such as Google Glass present another solution to this problem, and in fact provide far more flexible and robust experience than the Beam, though at the cost of labor. Remoting into another person through the first person camera, like the Beam, allows one to be anywhere, but unlike the Beam, preserves millions of years of evolution – walking and running, agile turning, flexible neck, opposable thumbs, etc. Although Glass can digitize the thumb, it can’t digitize dexterous hand motions.

As eyeware computers evolve into brain-controlling contact lenses and social norms and ethics adjust (if ever), perhaps we’ll be able to be anywhere, anytime through the Internet

It seems as if the global brain is a bit narrow in scope. Perhaps the Internet can be more broadly thought of as the global human.

The Pristine Story: Out of the Dark

We're out of the dark. After months of operating in stealth mode, we can finally discuss what we've accomplished.

We've built and are actively testing a HIPAA compliant, 1st person, audio and video streaming solution called Pristine EyeSight. We're streaming from Glass to any authorized device on the hospital's network.

We solve the problem of "Can you come over here and look at this?" This is a profound concept with a diverse set of use cases throughout virtually every avenue of care.

In addition to EyeSight, we've also built Pristine CheckLists. They are, as the name suggests, HIPAA compliant checklists on Glass. They're driving patient safety and operational efficiency. They're being tested at UC Irvine throughout perioperative settings. In time, we believe we'll implement checklists throughout the hospital. They're useful in situations in which the cost of being wrong is high.

We publicly unveiled these apps to the world on stage at the DEMO conference on October 17th. We won the coveted DEMOgod award. You can watch a recording of the presentation. I have to send a big shout out to Erick Schonfeld and Neal Silverman for putting on the DEMO conference. They did a spectacular job.

While I've been jumping from GlazedCon to Health 2.0 to the American College of Surgery to the American Society of Anesthesiology and to DEMO, Mark and Patrick have been doing the real work: piloting our software in live patient care environments with the doctors and nurses at UC Irvine Medical Center. We've been testing in inpatient surgery, outpatient surgery, the ICU, and the GI lab. We're still identifying the use cases and opportunities for these technologies throughout the hospital. There are so many to be tackled. Initial responses have been positive from almost everyone at Irvine, even though the product has a long ways to go.

Over the next few months, we're going to continue refining the product and user experience based on real-world feedback. Although the apps are functional today, there's an enormous amount of work to be done to deliver a world class user product. The devil is in the details.

Buzz and I will be heading to the FutureMed conference in San Diego November 2 - 6, and then to the New York eHealth Collaborative Conference Nov 14 - 15 in Manhattan. To round out the year, I'll be heading to San Fransisco December 6 - 8 and to themHealth Summit in Washington DC December 9 - 11.

And to round out this episode of The Pristine Story, some reading for your enjoyment:

HIStalk

Health IT Bubbles

Making Sense of Calico

HIStalk Interviews

Shiv Gaglani, Founder, Smartphone Physical

TechZulu

Why Google Fiber?

Getting Data In and Out of Your Electronic Health Record

Learning from the Smartphone Era: Building Consumer Glass Businesses

The Pristine Blog

The Marginal Value of the Smartphone

My Blog

Deliberate Writing

Over-Communicate